Originally Posted: August 17th, 2012
Today I would like to talk about something that makes me want to scream at people on the golf course. Yes, you guessed it from the title: Slow Play. It is a plague on the great game of golf. First off, none of us are playing for our livelihood or mortgage payments. We are basically playing for the sheer joy of the game. That being said: Why can we not finish a round of golf in less than 4 hours? One of the things that I think has slowed down play has been watching the pros play golf on TV, average players then hit the course and try to emulate them. I believe that this is a major contributing factor to slow play. The other culprit is that many times I see people just simply not ready to play when it is their turn. When it is your turn you should be over your ball and ready to strike, not pulling your club or determining the yardage or deciding on the type if shot to play. When it is your turn to hit you should be ready to hit and getting quickly into your pre-shot routine, if you have one.
Why do I mention this and why is it so important? I did a little analysis of what it takes to play a round of golf in 4 hours. A 4 hour round equates to approximately 13.33 minutes per hole. With 4 players, that means you have 3 minutes and 20 seconds to play each shot for each hole, that’s not a lot of time if you are walking, but if you take 20-30 seconds to set up your shot, that leaves you 2 minutes and 45 seconds to locate and walk to your ball. It’s also going to take more time to walk to your drive than your second shot to the green so things average out a bit there.
Let’s take an average par 4. Wikipedia claims average walking speed is about 3.1 mph. However, golfers are carrying or pushing a cart full of golf clubs so let’s cut that down by 20%. We are now at an average speed of 2.5mph, and if you do some quick math that comes out to about .82 seconds to traverse a yard. So now for some more math: For the sake of argument, we’ll use 250 yards as a drive distance and 150 yards as an approach shot. If it takes .82 seconds to walk a yard then it will take 3.4 min to get to your drive. If you have 3:20 per shot per hole, then you are already behind, but you get to make up some time as the second shot will only take you 2:03 to get to the green. Allowing 30 seconds for a pre-shot routine, club selection, etc., we have spent 6:23 of our allotted 13:20, which gives us 7 min to get the ball from on or around the green into the hole. In my mind, that seems entirely reasonable, so why does it not happen and why do we take so long on the green? I have come to the realization that we could speed up play on and around the greens if we made one simple change: Leave the pin in the cup until you are close, let’s say within 20 feet.
One thing I notice time and time again is that someone is on the green and ready to lag their putt to the hole, but they are waiting for someone to chip up or hit a bunker shot or some other short game pitch. The time that is spent waiting could be used to speed up play, and when you look at the numbers, the numbers don’t lie. I think you’ll agree this is something that amatuer golfers could really utilize in order to speed up play.
Below is an analysis of how long it takes to play an average round of golf. We’ll start with our goal of a 4 hour round, and add time as needed in order to demonstrate the major differences:
As you can plainly see, it would not take much to get onto that 4 hour pace and I believe it would be great for the game and make it much more enjoyable for all of us.
As for our main time saving idea: The idea of not removing the stick is going back to how the game was played for many years. Up until 1968, the flag remained in the cup and the player was allowed to put without removing the flag stick, and no penalty was attached should the ball strike the stick if the pin was unattended. Below is a short history of the rule for those of you who care.
The Flagstick (A short history of the rule):
First mention 1875, but certainly in use before then.
- 1875: Either party may have the flagstick removed when approaching the hole. This stayed in force until 1956.
- 1882: When a ball is within 20 yds of the hole, the flagstick must be removed (stroke play) – 1899 rules included a one stroke penalty for a breach. No penalty in match play for hitting the flagstick, attended or not.
- R&A 1888: When a ball rests against the flagstick, the stick may be removed.
- 1902: Loss of hole for striking a flagstick that had been removed by player’s own side. In stroke play, the flagstick must be removed before playing when ball from within 20 yards, penalty 1 stroke.
- 1908: Stroke play, rule changed to 2 strokes penalty for hitting the flagstick or a person standing at the hole. 1912: Word change to read ‘strikes, or is stopped by…’
- 1933: Loss of hole for striking a flagstick removed or held by the player’s own side – if held or removed by opponents, then THEY lost the hole. Stroke play rule unchanged.
- The 1952 code restated that striking an unattended flagstick from anywhere carried no penalty in match play, or from over 20 yards from the hole in stroke play. Striking the flagstick or the person attending it from within 20 yards carried a 2 stroke penalty.
- 1956 Rule was rewritten. Now the responsibilities and penalties fell to the player, and match and stroke play were treated the same. Two strokes or loss of hole if the player’s ball struck the flagstick or the person attending it. No penalty for striking an unattended flagstick from any distance.
- 1960: In adjusting the flagstick, the player may leave it at whatever angle it is found at, or set it upright. He cannot tilt the stick to his advantage (decision, 1956)
- 1968: Penalty of loss of hole or 2 strokes for hitting an unattended flagstick with stroke from the putting green.
It has always been the case that the flagstick can be removed when a ball is at rest against it and should the ball fall in, it is considered holed.
I believe that if we suspend the penalty for hitting the pin from the green (how often do you really hit the pin from 20+ feet anyway?) and allow players to putt up when the situation calls for it, pace of play would speed up. And although this will not fix everything, I think it could make up that 45 seconds per hole which equates out to 15 min for a round of 18 holes.
That’s the idea anyway. If you have any other ideas let’s hear them. If you want take this idea and run with it, I would be very interested to the results you’re able to achieve on the golf course.